Tuesday, Oct. 5, 2010
Eagle Pass, Texas

7:00 a.m.

Eighteen-year-old Juan Mendez Jr. wakes his second cousin, 15-year-old Jesse Cazares. Instead of going to school, they begin a short journey that ends with Mendez shot twice and dying on a lawn of a West Texas subdivision.

The cousins drive in a white Ford utility truck to a bend in the Rio Grande River outside of town.

Mendez shooting marijuana
These bundles of marijuana, weighing 320 pounds and valued at $256,000, were in the bed of the truck that Juan Mendez Jr. was driving.
Credit: Courtesy of the Maverick County district attorney’s office

Mendez shooting marijuana

Mendez shooting marijuana

These bundles of marijuana, weighing 320 pounds and valued at $256,000, were in the bed of the truck that Juan Mendez Jr. was driving.


There, several men run out from the brush and throw bundles of marijuana into the truck bed.

8:30 a.m.

U.S. Border Patrol camera operators report over the radio that a white pickup truck “just loaded up in the 1290 area.”

Border Patrol agents on duty that morning, including Taylor Poitevent, receive a call to locate and identify a possible narcotics trafficker near Kypuros Road.

Poitevent spots the white truck on Kypuros Road, and it accelerates as it passes his patrol vehicle. He follows the truck.

"I followed the white truck as it sped down Kypuros Road and turned onto Wichita Circle. As I was following the white truck, I attempted to run the license plate." — Taylor Poitevent
Border Patrol agent

Over the radio, other Border Patrol agents hear Poitevent report that the suspects are looking for a place to bail out.

They’ve turned onto Wichita Circle, a dead-end residential street.

Mendez stops the truck at the end of the street and tells his cousin to run.

Mendez truck


While being chased by the Border Patrol, Juan Mendez Jr. and his cousin abandoned this utility truck on Wichita Circle, which ends in a cul-de-sac.
Credit: Courtesy of the Maverick County district attorney’s office

Cazares scales the wooden fence separating the subdivision from the river. When he looks back, he sees Mendez pulled off the fence by a Border Patrol agent.

Mendez begins to struggle with Poitevent.

A neighbor, Adriana Aranda, hears fighting outside and goes to investigate.

"That's when I see the Border Patrol (agent) sitting on top of the guy, punching the guy on the back and saying, 'You motherfucker, you motherfucker.'" — Adriana Aranda

Her husband, Joe Andrade, also steps outside after hearing the commotion.

During the struggle, Poitevent notices that the retention strap on his gun holster is open and fears Mendez is trying to grab his service pistol.

"I was able to regain my balance and attempted to subdue Mendez again. He swung at me and struck me extremely hard in the head with his fist." — Taylor Poitevent
Border Patrol agent

8:35 a.m.

Poitevent is tiring from his struggle with Mendez. After the blow to his head, he fears he may be losing consciousness, and if he blacks out, Mendez could take his weapon and use it against him or a bystander. This is when he draws his gun.

"I stopped firing when I saw Mendez's silhouette go down." — Taylor Poitevent
Border Patrol agent


 After seeing Poitevent shoot Mendez, Andrade asks him if he needs help, and then watches him make a call on his cellphone.

" 'I had to shoot him, I thought he was coming back at me.' The Border Patrol agent started crying and said also, when he hung up, 'Oh man, I hope I don't get convicted for this.' " — Joe Andrade

Poitevent’s call was to Border Patrol Agent Hector Nunez.

"Poitevent sounded upset and would not respond to my questions and would keep repeating 'shots fired' and that he needed backup and EMS." — Hector Nunez
Border Patrol agent

Mendez shooting scene


Markers dot the shooting scene on Wichita Circle after Border Patrol Agent Taylor Poitevent shot and killed Juan Mendez Jr., who was unarmed.
Credit: Courtesy of the Maverick County district attorney’s office

8:41 a.m.

Border Patrol Agent Matt Sachse arrives at the scene, where he sees Poitevent kneeling on all fours.

"As I approached him, he looked up and said, 'Sachse, he's gone, he's gone.' " — Matt Sachse
Border Patrol agent

Poitevent tells Sachse that he struck Mendez with his baton, but it had no effect. After Mendez hit him in the head, Poitevent said he was afraid of losing consciousness and, not knowing what to do next, shot him.

8:53 a.m.

More Border Patrol agents and emergency medical personnel arrive at the scene of the shooting.

"I saw Agent (Charles Andrew) Rabaut attempting to handcuff the subject and I asked him if he had checked his vital signs. … I checked the subject for a pulse and was unable to find one." — Javier Lopez
Border Patrol agent

Mendez diagram


A rough sketch of the crime scene shows Border Patrol Agent Taylor Poitevent and Juan Mendez Jr.'s positions after the shooting.
Credit: Texas Department of Public Safety, Texas Ranger Division

9:21 a.m.

Mendez is taken to an Eagle Pass hospital, where he is declared dead.

Mendez autopsy


A diagram from Juan Mendez Jr.'s autopsy shows his bullet wounds.
Credit: Texas Department of Public Safety, Texas Ranger Division

Mendez's body is taken to Laredo, Texas, for an autopsy because Maverick County does not have a medical examiner. There, blood tests reveal he had both marijuana and cocaine in his system.


Quoted material in this story came from the Texas Rangers' investigation report on the shooting of Juan Mendez Jr.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Sam Ward is a former senior digital producer for Reveal, where he oversees the web team. He has years of experience producing creative digital media projects for Oregon Public Broadcasting, PBS, ITVS and the Smithsonian, and he has managed projects for funders such as the National Science Foundation, U.S. Department of Education and Annenberg Media. He graduated from Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh. Ward is based in Reveal's Emeryville, California, office.

Andrew Becker is a reporter for Reveal, covering border, national and homeland security issues, as well as weapons and gun trafficking. He has focused on waste, fraud and abuse – with stories ranging from border corruption to the expanding use of drones and unmanned aerial vehicles, from the militarization of police to the intersection of politics and policy related to immigration, from terrorism to drug trafficking. Becker's reporting has appeared in The Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, The New York Times, Newsweek/The Daily Beast and on National Public Radio and PBS/FRONTLINE, among others. He received a master's degree in journalism from UC Berkeley. Becker is based in Reveal's Emeryville, California, office.